Shoutbox

dp: dude
376 days ago

Bango_Rilla: Shout Bananas!!
331 days ago

BillyBlastOff: See you kiddies at the Convention!
315 days ago

GDW: showman
266 days ago

Emilien03: https://losg...
188 days ago

Pyronauts: Happy Tanks-Kicking!!!
181 days ago

glennmagi: CLAM SHACK guitar
167 days ago

Hothorseraddish: surf music is amazing
147 days ago

dp: get reverberated!
98 days ago

Clint: “A Day at the Beach” podcast #237 is TWO HOURS of NEW surf music releases. https://link...
31 days ago

Please login or register to shout.

IRC Status
  • racc

Join them in the #ShallowEnd!

Need help getting started?

Current Polls

No polls at this time. Check out our past polls.

Current Contests

No contests at this time. Check out our past contests.

Donations

Help us meet our monthly goal:

100%

100%

Donate Now

Cake May Birthdays Cake
SG101 Banner

SurfGuitar101 Forums » Surf Music General Discussion »

Permalink What elements would create the ultimate surf song?

New Topic
Goto Page: 1 2 Next

There are certain surf/instrumental songs which have amazing parts. What if they were all put together in an ultimate song?

The build-up of journey to the stars, the guitar intro of misirlou, the drum rolls of k-39. I would like to hypothetically construct the ultimate surf anthem.

Last edited: Aug 06, 2015 12:07:46

The perfect melody played by somebody that felt it, that and some liberal reverb.

Too often, I feel some bands are just playing guitar instead of writing music. We get these guitar parts that are really compact with too many notes and not enough variance in those notes.

I'd personally like to see more animated bass parts as well, playing a sort of counterpoint to the lead guitar. That is something I really enjoy, surprising we don't see more of it. Drums, more dynamics!

JakeDobner wrote:

The perfect melody played by somebody that felt it, that and some liberal reverb.

Too often, I feel some bands are just playing guitar instead of writing music. We get these guitar parts that are really compact with too many notes and not enough variance in those notes.

I'd personally like to see more animated bass parts as well, playing a sort of counterpoint to the lead guitar. That is something I really enjoy, surprising we don't see more of it. Drums, more dynamics!

I especialy agree on the bass comment. A simple bassline has its place, but it's refreshing to hear when someone explores the neck more. One of my all-time favorite bass-lines is the Lively Ones - Surf Rider. I like it much better than the Ventures version.

Regarding guitar, I'm a sucker fast and hard staccato notes, but then there's the slow spacey songs that really get me emotionally as well using very little notes.

martianspy wrote:

What if they were all put together in an ultimate song?

I get it... it's a theoretical experiment. It exposes a narrative though (reflecting my personal rant)-
That's exactly how big budget Hollywood works today. Take everything that's (supposedly) awesome or cool, put it together in a big pot (not even stir!) and throw dollars at it. That's why there wasn't a real great movie in the last 25 years, since Pulp-Fiction, really.
The result is soulless excellence, no meaning, zero emotional impact, and zero staying power. Millions of $$$, best set designers, amazing actors, huge productions - all amount to nothing.
That methodology is quite contradicting the spirit of surf, IMO, but who am I to say. Not that excellence shouldn't be pursued, of course, but generally the charm of a good musical idea comes from context, not as stand alone.
the whole is bigger than the sum of it's parts, in this case anyway...

I recall a wonderful scene from "Immortal Beloved"- about Beethoven, when his close friends expressed deep concern for his mental health, evident by his deteriorating musical ability, since his latest, still unreleased symphony's main motive sounded stupid and infantile when sung drunkenly by one of them, at the restaurant's table. "Ta ta ta ta Ta ta ta ta Ta ta ta ta Taaa Ta TAAAA." Cool

Last edited: Aug 06, 2015 13:59:36

The 4th movement of the 9th... I think it is mankind's greatest musical achievement. I highly suggest the Beethoven's 9th iPad app to anybody with that device.

I haven't meant to kill the thread like that, but someone mentioned "best"...
BTW I saw that movie again just yesterday. Impressive, but not good. No much insight in the musical psyche (unlike "Amadeus"), just extreme romantics and overstated blanket psychology. Meh.

JakeDobner wrote:

The 4th movement of the 9th... I think it is mankind's greatest musical achievement. I highly suggest the Beethoven's 9th iPad app to anybody with that device.

Will it help me enjoy it more? Expose new layers of appreciation?
Just kidding, I'm on Android Big Grin

I'm on Android myself, I hate iOS. The Beethoven app and Crossword puzzles are the only apps I have besides music making apps. iPads are pretty useless... but I own one...

And Amadeus, there is a top 5 movie for me! That laugh...

Because all music comes down to personal choice on any given day, how can there be an ultimate? I understand the question and the concept. I don't know how to conceive an answer. Does music continually evolve?

I'm gonna cram in all in to one glorious swan song. You'll see. It will be the soundtrack for the release of my manifesto to the public. I will call it surfin surf surfer.

The perfect surf song is not too long. Definitely less than three minutes.

http://thewaterboarders.bandcamp.com/

I like introductions with a strong hook line which then immediately changes direction, then at a later point in the song reintroducing the riff. Some might say the riff is good enough to make a whole song but that's not the point, the idea is to ambush and tease the listener never quite giving them what they want.

Got to love Jimi Hendrix - Stone Free at the end where goes in hyper drive.. Oh man we're going into space!! oh c**p it's fade out and end of song!

from SG101 News Story #31, originally written in 2002:

"There is an important fourth element- arrangement, or when recording- production. I think it is extremely important not to confuse arrangement/production with song writing. Arrangements define a genre rather than a song. A good song should be able to be arranged for a variety of genres. But to start out the song writing process by saying, well I'm going to have a glissando going into a reverb kick followed by the drum lick to Wipe Out and then the bassline to Pipeline with some pingy notes on top, will create a completely unoriginal, paint by numbers surf song. And, to my ear, there is lot of that happening in surf music these days. Arrangements are the wrapping for the present, but don't skimp on the gift for fancy paper and bows."

Buy Endless Drummer @ Bandcamp
Frankie and the Pool Boys website
Buy Speed of Dark @ Bandcamp
Pollo Del Mar website
My Blog- Euro Tour Blog
Pool Boys on Spotify
INSTAGRAM
Frankie & The Pool Boys on Facebook
Pollo Del Mar on Facebook
DJ Frankie Pool Boy on North Sea Surf Radio

da-ron wrote:

The perfect surf song is not too long. Definitely less than three minutes.

Yes, da-ron is right. I agree.
And THE length for a surf song lies between 2:33min and 2:35min. Or 2:32min and 2:35min.
I am practicing surf music science since 17 years and there will be no end.
There are also a few songs with 2 minutes plusminus a few seconds. (Astronauts songs, Pyramids,...)
I know at last the length will tell nothing about the quality of a song of course.
But the length could be an element for "the ultimate surf song"?

Listen always to NSSR and the Fantastic Five shows there. I try to explain such things.

Twang cheers!

Ralf Kilauea

www.kilaueas.de

https://kilaueas.bandcamp.com/album/touch-my-alien

Jake covered a lot of it, here is my take:

Melody line
Feeling and personal style
Arrangement including nice middle 8!
TONE (preferably more individualistic as opposed to copying standard tone)
REVERB to taste
Counterpoint
2-3 minutes
Catchy title
Oh, and must go back in time machine and record between 1959 - 1964 Cool

Surf.The most dangerous of genres...

Surfcat

MARCH OF THE DEAD SURFERS! (2024) - Agent Octopus
THE JOURNEY HOME - Free download (2025) - Agent Octopus (Single)

YOUTUBE - Agent Octopus Surf
BANDCAMP - Reverb Galaxy

PolloGuitar wrote:

from SG101 News Story #31, originally written in 2002:

"There is an important fourth element- arrangement, or when recording- production. I think it is extremely important not to confuse arrangement/production with song writing. Arrangements define a genre rather than a song. A good song should be able to be arranged for a variety of genres. But to start out the song writing process by saying, well I'm going to have a glissando going into a reverb kick followed by the drum lick to Wipe Out and then the bassline to Pipeline with some pingy notes on top, will create a completely unoriginal, paint by numbers surf song. And, to my ear, there is lot of that happening in surf music these days. Arrangements are the wrapping for the present, but don't skimp on the gift for fancy paper and bows."

Interesting re-read, Ferenc! I am curious what you will think of the songs we recorded a few weeks ago, especially in reference to what you said about trios in the article. Can I send you some rough mixes once they are done?

I personally find it hard to seperate songwriting from arranging, since I always hold it important to create some diversity inside of a song (although writing something totally homogenous (yet entertaining) would also be an interesting challenge). So early on in the process I try to remind myself of the different "textures" we have available as surf guitarists: single notes, muted single notes, double picked single notes; double stops, chords etc.

Technically the way you play a part is an apsect of arranging, but I usually start songwriting with a meldoy or a riff and after I have that the question is: Where interesting can I go from here? If the melody is played as single notes on the upper strings, a riff on the lower strings or a chain of chords can provide a nice balance. Next question: Do I need something in between the melody and the next part? If yes, what would make sense?

So in my case songwriting and arranging are closely connected, to better results I hope. Uh-Oh

Los Apollos - cinematic surf music trio (Berlin)
"Postcards from the Scrapyard" Vol. 1, 2 & 3 NOW available on various platforms!
"Chaos at the Lobster Lounge" available as LP and download on Surf Cookie Records!

Every genre has those elements that identify it. Use enough of the elements, and the result is plausibly within the genre. Use none of them, and you are nearly certainly out of it.

But using all of the elements usually results in the paint-by-numbers mentioned above.

Could you have a surf song without reverb? Certainly, and as much as you can have one without a glissando or reverb crash.

As for the separation of songwriting from arrangement, consider this. A good melody can be arranged in multiple ways. And that's nearly the definition of a good melody.

Only 7 elements needed...

Rhenium, Re
Vanadium, V
Erbium, Er
Boron, B

Tantalum, Ta
Nitrogen, N
Potassium, K

Clarry wrote:

Only 7 elements needed...

Rhenium, Re
Vanadium, V
Erbium, Er
Boron, B

Tantalum, Ta
Nitrogen, N
Potassium, K

Awesome! Do these actually combine in any way to form something?

Surf.The most dangerous of genres...

Surfcat

MARCH OF THE DEAD SURFERS! (2024) - Agent Octopus
THE JOURNEY HOME - Free download (2025) - Agent Octopus (Single)

YOUTUBE - Agent Octopus Surf
BANDCAMP - Reverb Galaxy

To illustrate my point about not confusing songwriting with arrangement, here are some great surf songs to check out:

Buy Endless Drummer @ Bandcamp
Frankie and the Pool Boys website
Buy Speed of Dark @ Bandcamp
Pollo Del Mar website
My Blog- Euro Tour Blog
Pool Boys on Spotify
INSTAGRAM
Frankie & The Pool Boys on Facebook
Pollo Del Mar on Facebook
DJ Frankie Pool Boy on North Sea Surf Radio

Last edited: Aug 12, 2015 11:16:34

flip wrote:

Its funny because different people zero in on different things. I was talking to a friend who was telling me XYZ band is amazing... I could bot get where he was coming from. Eventually It became clear it was lyrics. Something I notice last (if at all).
I think the above illustrates that melody is king. You can add all the trimmings you want to be sure, but a brilliant melody is timeless

www.reverbnation.com/thetahitishuttleexperiment
www.facebook.com/pages/The-Tahiti-Shuttle-Experiment/144705578903043
www.tahitishuttleexperiment.com

Goto Page: 1 2 Next
Top