Posted on Dec 02 2023 08:02 PM
I've got one of Dario's complete El Sonido's - the Bassman head w/ 2x12 cabinet. It originally came with Celestion Vintage 30's in it. Really good, but not 'most amazing' to MY EAR, for what I was playing.
I started asking the same 'speaker recommendations?' question here. With several resounding endorsements of the ElectroVoice EVM-12L's, I made the jump. Glorious... to be sure. Heavy AF... to be sure. But, but, but!! Glorious. I immediately and significantly preferred them by comparison to the V30's.
FFWD with a few refinements to the head (Mercury Magnetics 6G6-B vintage spec transformers & choke, plus some NOS Tung-Sol power tubes and a great NOS/ANOS RCA black plate 7025 for the 'Wild" (2nd) channel), and the recommendation from a highly regarded local amp tech with many, many years in vintage amps and part of Steve Carr's operation (Carr Amps) as THEE warranty service guy for years... I took his recommendation and tried the Celestion Heritage Series G12-65's.
The irony, this speaker was created in the 70's "using more modern materials and techniques for a higher power handling", proclaimed to be the best for a 4x12 (looking at you Marshall!) and according to my tech, rose to prominence in the 80's rock and metal scene... they are simply SUBLIME, INCREDIBLE in my El Sonido for instrumental & surf that we all know and love - both vintage / vintage inspired and modern (and anything in between).
To me, they sound WAY better than the Vintage 30's (note, I had the imports if that matters to you), and IN MY OPINION and TO MY EAR, distinctly better than the EV's.
The EV's were absolutely strong - clean, crisp, clear and without any speaker breakup and if it is possible to truly know, what seemed to be without coloration. They sounded real nice. Real real nice. Of course, thanks to the very high efficiency rating, they were also plenty loud.
That said, the Heritage G12-65 speaker experiment has added to my confirmation bias that part of what made the old stuff so great is/was the less efficient, less pristine qualities of components of the day. Not lo-fi, just less efficient and ever so slightly less naturally clean and giving (firm/stiff) than the EVM 12L's.
For me, the G12-65's really deliver. BIG TIME.
Plenty clean and crisp, natural/neutral and plenty loud (efficiency rating), but with a rich full spectrum; complex is the best way to describe it. Straight 10 foot cord from guitar to amp and it is almost like having the outboard Gomez G-Spring (6G15 clone) plugged in with a very light reverb setting. I now understand the comment "3-D" with the richness WITHOUT any reverb or delay. So, so good.
Now, the Band Master is NOT the Bassman circuit despite similar wattage and 2x12 configuration. That said, I could not be more pleased with making the switch from ElectroVoice EVM-12L's to the G12-65's and if I ever found myself with a vintage Band Master, I would absolutely give the Heritage G12-65's a go - before EV's even.
FWIW, My 2 cents, YMMV, etc. etc. etc.
—
Fady
El Mirage @ ReverbNation