
Posted on Jun 23 2014 12:50 PM
The real answer? Whatever sounds best to you.
Ok... Let's see.. Running through my basses over the last 35 years that I have. Note: they are generally either played thru a Fender Musicmaster Bass amp with a 15" or a GK600 with a single 15". I use rotosounds and never changed them. The Bass VI has what was put on at the factory.
The 1969 Gibson Eb-3, 30" scale. VERY hard to get a good sound out of it. You need a good active box or amp with active controls to get rid of all the mud. It was designed when amps/performances/venues.. everything was smaller. (and yes. I know they still make them and Jack Bruce Trevor Bolder and a slew of guys played them.. But they were also using the technology of then. Playing with picks, etc.) Every so often i'll pull it out to play and it's fun and balanced, but never a good sound.
The 1989 Squier (MIJ) Jazz bass. All around-fantastic slim fast low action neck. trouble free until last month and a pot shorted out. I replaced that with a CTS. I felt bad that I had to ream out the hole in the plate for the larger shaft mount.
But.. the tone is great with basic controls. I'm a huge fan of passive controls on the bass and do actually turn those knobs. Sounds great thru a Mesa 400, a Fender Musicmaster bass amp and currently, a GK-600.
Early 90s Fender (MIJ) Bass VI reissue. Only instrument that I've had a pickup go out. Thin cheap wiring, floppy switches. The bass plays pretty well, but it is more of a niche. I can see it for some surf, 60s pop and related. I can't see myself using it for hard rock, etc. it just doesn't deliver the BASS. I did find it to be a good complement when you have a keyboard player in the group. I also like it when accompanying a couple of acoustic players. you're adding bass but not driving the band/sound with it. I also used it in a mod/power pop band and it also matched the guitar players 67 Fender XII.
2006 Epiphone Thunderbird. A friend of mine gave me this for Christmas one year. I have always loved the style and shape of the Fire/Thunderbirds. It's heavy, has humbuckers, decent controls. As it was a gift, I started playing that a lot without ever really COMPARING it to the others. Action is decent. I played that in my hard rock/early punk band for years.
So last fall I started a new band. More 70s guitar driven bluesy boogie van stuff. I started with the Thunderbird but I forgot how clubby the neck was and how long it felt.. and heavy. I tried the Jazz at the next practice and bang... it all fell into place. great speed on the narrow neck, super low action, great tone control, lighter.
So my "vote" is a jazz bass for surf. I think you have the speed/action for runs, you can dial in a dark or bright sound whereas the standard P has only one pickup.
You also open up the possibilities of matching the rest of the group with colors and all that. Visually, people often associate surf and Fenders in custom colors.
I have heard good things about the Jaguar basses, fender has a slew of basses in all kinds of combos of neck profiles, pickups.. almost endless.
And not to mention all the other 1000s that are out there. look with your ears first.