Photo of the Day
Shoutbox

dp: dude
347 days ago

Bango_Rilla: Shout Bananas!!
302 days ago

BillyBlastOff: See you kiddies at the Convention!
286 days ago

GDW: showman
237 days ago

Emilien03: https://losg...
159 days ago

Pyronauts: Happy Tanks-Kicking!!!
152 days ago

glennmagi: CLAM SHACK guitar
138 days ago

Hothorseraddish: surf music is amazing
118 days ago

dp: get reverberated!
68 days ago

Clint: “A Day at the Beach” podcast #237 is TWO HOURS of NEW surf music releases. https://link...
2 days ago

Please login or register to shout.

IRC Status
  • racc

Join them in the #ShallowEnd!

Need help getting started?

Current Polls

No polls at this time. Check out our past polls.

Current Contests

No contests at this time. Check out our past contests.

Donations

Help us meet our monthly goal:

35%

35%

Donate Now

Cake April Birthdays Cake
SG101 Banner

SurfGuitar101 Forums » Gear »

Permalink Please recommend replacement 12" speaker for 20w tube amp

New Topic
Goto Page: 1 2 Next

Could any recommend a good replacement for an aging Jensen 12" (AlNiCo, I think) that is installed in my ca. 1960 tweed Gibson GA20T Ranger amp. The amp is approximately equivalent to a Fender Deluxe of the same period, with two channels with two inputs each, one with a tremolo circuit.
It's such a nice-sounding amp, but the old Jensen seriously farts out in the lower end and has no headroom. Nowadays I am into cleaner sounds and more technical picking than I was even a few years back and I want this amp to be able to handle surf styles at moderate volume.
I'd like a more 'hi-fi' speaker which works well with a small amp like this.
Thanks!

Squink Out!

Weber 12A125A

He who dies with the most tubes... wins

Surf Daddies

Dope? Ribs? What are you observations of the sound of this speaker, tubeswell?
I know the 12A 125A is a copy of the original Jensen – but will it make the amp more gigworthy? Like,more bottom end, less breakup at volume?

Squink Out!

30W ribbed version if you want bottom end. Very gig-worthy in a 20W amp. You need to break them in for a wee while when you first get them out of the box. Or go to the model with '150' sized speaker coil. Another very gig-worthy speaker in that type of amp would be a Celestion G12 20W (Heritage series) - really about a 25W speaker, but sounds amazing with low powered amps.

He who dies with the most tubes... wins

Surf Daddies

Last edited: Jun 03, 2013 13:21:34

I cheaped out and got an Eminence Cannabis Rex, 50W capacity, for $77 + tax, delivered in 36 hrs.

Still breaking the cone in, but right away the heavier new driver brings back some clarity and oomph to the 20 W Gibson that the puny P12Q didn't deliver – especially with the Gibson Reverb III dialed in. The wet signal was so distorted it was unpleasant and the overall lo-fi sound was really discouraging me from playing the amp.

Installing the new Cannabis Rex, I had to torque the right 6V6 tube to clear the very broad magnet housing. The tube is still not entirely clear of it but now it only presses gently against the rubber gasket surrounding the magnet. I foresee some problems eventually with that tube jimmied like that, especially if vibration is transmitted. I folded aluminum foil as a heat sink between the tube and the gasket.

Now I can turn the amp up all the way without overmuch distortion and modulate volume with picking for a smoothly compressed sound. Fuzz works less well than overdrive with the setup. I haven't tried tape delay yet. The Gibson GA20T is a very musical two-channel amp with excellent onboard tremolo. An A/B switch gives me access to both of the differently-voiced channels: Bright w/tremolo and Dark w/o. The Ranger is comparable to the Ampeg Jet and the more famous Fender Deluxe. I'm glad to have something surfable that's smaller and less loud than my Twin.

I haven't noticed anything amiss using a speaker with twice the capacity of the amp's output. One thing I do hear, that also happens with my 12W Gretsch Electromatic Twin, is that there are basically 3 volume levels available. The amp doesn't get appreciably louder from half-cranked to dimed. Only way to go to "11" is with gain stage pedals, of which I have plenty.

Squink Out!

JObeast wrote:

Installing the new Cannabis Rex, I had to torque the right 6V6 tube to clear the very broad magnet housing. The tube is still not entirely clear of it but now it only presses gently against the rubber gasket surrounding the magnet. I foresee some problems eventually with that tube jimmied like that, especially if vibration is transmitted. I folded aluminum foil as a heat sink between the tube and the gasket.

Yes I agree there will be problems. I wouldn't count on the bottle's glass envelope lasting very long with all the heat and vibration, and once it fails there's the killer voltage still present on the plates, which will be touching the speaker magnet, which if it is metal, will be bad to touch.

He who dies with the most tubes... wins

Surf Daddies

I do have a box full of tubes so I might win after all when I get electrocuted through my flatwounds when this happens.
It's not much pressure, it barely touches the fat rubber grommet surrounding the housing. I just can get it altogether clear unless I can modify the baffle angle or cant the tube socket permanently. Ever done that? I imagine I would have to drill out the rivets, mount the socket with an angled baseplate and re-rivet it back together.
tubeswell wrote:

JObeast wrote:

Installing the new Cannabis Rex, I had to torque the right 6V6 tube to clear the very broad magnet housing. The tube is still not entirely clear of it but now it only presses gently against the rubber gasket surrounding the magnet. I foresee some problems eventually with that tube jimmied like that, especially if vibration is transmitted. I folded aluminum foil as a heat sink between the tube and the gasket.

Yes I agree there will be problems. I wouldn't count on the bottle's glass envelope lasting very long with all the heat and vibration, and once it fails there's the killer voltage still present on the plates, which will be touching the speaker magnet, which if it is metal, will be bad to touch.

Squink Out!

Cool amp you have. Mine is a '58 GA40 Gibson, and I've tried many different speakers. There was no problem with clearance on the CRex, which was excellent in that amp. As was a Weber Cali ceramic. Now using a WGS Blackhawk 50, sort of in the Celestion Gold camp. As loud as the CRex, maybe louder. No early breakup as on the original Jensens. When it does drive, what wonderful sounds.
MD

I had one of those awesome amps once too, a two-tone.the tweed version is super-valuable now, hardly 'undervalued' the way Gibson amps all were 15 years ago.

I might do something about reducing the baffle angle a few degrees so I can get correct clearance for the magnet surround. It's nice to have a working 20-watt amp for a change, so I do't have to run the 85 or 100 w Twin every time my fingers itch.

Squink Out!

JObeast wrote:

I cheaped out and got an Eminence Cannabis Rex, 50W capacity, for $77 + tax, delivered in 36 hrs.

Excellent choice. I just bought what seems to be an Eminence Neodymium Deltalite with a Tone Tubby hemp reconing. It sounds magnificent for clean guitar tones, and I'm thrilled. I expect yours sounds similar.

Insanitizers! http://www.insanitizers.com

I understand the that you like the C-Rex speaker but I would not modify a vintage amp to allow tube clearance. You might consider reconing the vintage Alnico Jensen or finding something else with a smaller ceramic magnet to clear the power tube. The ceramic magnet would be typically cleaner when driver hard.

Keep it Drippy Brothers and Sisters!

Hammond, You're right. Any permanent mod is to be avoided. I might shim the chassis mounting to get it to hang at an angle. So far the intrusion of the big magnet surround is not pressing much on the tube, which is canted a little to accommodate it. I wish I had thought about the issue first but how to measure sight unseen? A neodymium speaker with its compact assembly would be the answer. Or maybe sell the Cannabis (hehe) and get a Weber with bell housing like the Jensen AlniCo.

Squink Out!

Does anyone have experience with the Weber 12F150's bell housing – how it compares with the dimensions of a Jensen AlNiCo like the P12R? Apparently it fits Fender Tweed Deluxe amps perfectly (wider cabinet than the Gibson GA20T) Or the NeoMag 12"?

Squink Out!

JObeast, as per your original posted question, I'd get that old Jensen re-coned.
I've tried a lot of newer speakers and nothing, in my opinion, comes close to an old speaker or even an old speaker re-coned properly. It's hard to beat those old magnets and the heating/cooling/demagnetizing they've done in the last 50-60 years.
Modern equivalents sound fine, even great but never as good as the old ones, at least to my ears.

http://www.facebook.com/CrazyAcesMusic
http://www.youtube.com/user/crazyacesrock
http://www.reverbnation.com/crazyacesmusic

JO:

The Weber 12F150 doesn't have a bell housing. At least the ones I've seen didn't. It's ceramic magnet, a big, flat magnet in the back. So it takes up space in a different way. Not as deep, but does go wider at the back of the speaker, than the typical alnico with bell housing.
MD

JObeast, Selling the C-Rex might be a good idea. Too bad you don't have two of them. Maybe we could work something out. I have a low power tweed Twin I built and I have a pair of Weber Neo 12s in it. For what I want out of the amp, a smooth tweed breakup when pushed, the Neo 12s are two clean and brittle when I push the amp with bluesy program. I've thought of trying the C-Rex.

If you want to road trip out to Wildomar you are welcome to bolt a Neo 12 in to see if you like it. Personally I think Neos, the ones built as JBL clones (Weber)work best with amps that have more clean headroom, Twins, Showmans, etc. They really sound good in the tweed Twin up to the point the amp hits the sweet spot then all bets are off. I'd drive that old Jensen down to Orange County Speaker and have it reconed. Should cost about as much as the C-Rex.

Keep it Drippy Brothers and Sisters!

Tone Tubby!!!

-BAM BAM-

Well, I sold the old Jensen P12R today rather than spending $100 to recone it. I sort of doubt it was original to the amp anyhow. I am selling the two C12N SICA Jensens from my SF Twin as well, and may take the Cannabis Rex out of the Ginson Ranger to put into the Twin along with another new speaker.
I like the sound of the Twin with the Jensens until I use OD – then it sounds plasticky, like a recording of distorted guitar. Selling the 2000-mfr. Jensen ceramics will afford me replacements that may be more usable with fuzz and OD.
Thinking of a Eminence Li'l Texas Neodymium 75W-rated driver with a Tone Tubby Hemp cone for the Gibson – the tweed circuit distorts very nicely so I am thinking a hi-fi type driver let make it shine across a broader frequency spectrum.
Suggestions? (affordable, and surfable)

Squink Out!

Last edited: Nov 13, 2013 23:40:13

You can replace the paper dust covers in the Jensen C12Ns with hard felt and the fizzy, ugly tone when using OD and distortion will go away. They will sound more like vintage Chicago C12Ns.

You can get hard felt at a fabric store or order precut discs from Weber.

Just sayin'

Keep it Drippy Brothers and Sisters!

Hammond101, that's a cool idea!

http://www.facebook.com/CrazyAcesMusic
http://www.youtube.com/user/crazyacesrock
http://www.reverbnation.com/crazyacesmusic

Goto Page: 1 2 Next
Top