Photo of the Day
BTD
BTD
Shoutbox

sysmalakian: Birthday month starts now!
363 days ago

diceophonic: Vampiro Classics 2024 reissue
344 days ago

SabedLeepski: Sunburn Surf Fest for some scorching hot surf music: https://sunb...
301 days ago

skeeter: I know a Polish sound guy.
229 days ago

skeeter: I know a Czech one too!
229 days ago

PatGall: Surfybear metal settings
149 days ago

Pyronauts: Happy Tanks-Kicking!
127 days ago

midwestsurfguy: Merry Christmas!
95 days ago

sysmalakian: HAPPY NEW YEAR!
89 days ago

SabedLeepski: Surfin‘ Europe, for surf (related) gigs and events in Europe Big Razz https://sunb...
50 days ago

Please login or register to shout.

Current Polls

No polls at this time. Check out our past polls.

Current Contests

No contests at this time. Check out our past contests.

Donations

Help us meet our monthly goal:

100%

100%

Donate Now

Cake March Birthdays Cake
SG101 Banner

SurfGuitar101 Forums » Gear »

Permalink Differences Between Strat, Jaguar, and Jazzmaster Pickups

New Topic
Goto Page: 1 2 Next

Perhaps some of our more experienced members can give a rundown on the difference between these pickups. I realize that an apples to apples comparison is unrealistic; there are plenty of differences between the guitars, tailpiece/bridge, scale-length, etc. But I’d be curious, especially about the differences between the Jag pickup and the Strat pickup. Has anyone ever found a way to get close to a Jaguar sound from a Strat? Has anyone ever done a Jazzmaster with Jaguar pickups?

I’ve been missing my Jaguar latel, but strongly prefer the longer scale of a Strat or Jazzmaster. Is there a way to have a longer scale guitar with the punch of a Jaguar?

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

image

Fender released these a little while ago.
I believe Eddie Katcher has a stealth Jazzmaster with Jag pups under the covers. Jeff Senn/CrazyAces built a long scale Jag back a while ago. And I think SlacktoneDave might have built one.

I think the main difference in sound between Jaguar and Strat is in the bridge pickup. I find you can get very similar sounds with neck pickups. But bridge pickups in Strats seem thinner to me, while the Jaguar bridge is more focused and biting. It may have to do with the windings or maybe the Jaguar claw makes some kind of difference there.

I think your best approach would be to get a Jazzmaster body routed for Jaguar pickups - it would preserve most of the other aspects of Jaguarness but let you have the long scale.

Surf_Skater wrote:

image

Fender released these a little while ago.
I believe Eddie Katcher has a stealth Jazzmaster with Jag pups under the covers. Jeff Senn/CrazyAces built a long scale Jag back a while ago. And I think SlacktoneDave might have built one.

The idea of a stealth Jazzmaster is intriguing. I bet that you could confuse the aficionados in the audience with such a rig.

edwardsand wrote:

I think the main difference in sound between Jaguar and Strat is in the bridge pickup. I find you can get very similar sounds with neck pickups. But bridge pickups in Strats seem thinner to me, while the Jaguar bridge is more focused and biting. It may have to do with the windings or maybe the Jaguar claw makes some kind of difference there.

I think your best approach would be to get a Jazzmaster body routed for Jaguar pickups - it would preserve most of the other aspects of Jaguarness but let you have the long scale.

That makes a lot of sense. I’ve had a couple of great Strats, in the past, but the bridge pickups on either of them were relatively thin sounding.

I wish that I could get a Jaguar body with the bridge routed for a long scale. I love the control set on a Jaguar, including the chromed plates for mounting the switches and pots. I do t know why, but that look has always appealed to me. Besides that, the Jaguar can do Country sounds as well as a Tele. When I had my CIJ ‘66 Jag RI (with Seymour Duncan pickups), I once astonished a Tele player I was working with, by matching his bridge pickup sound, very closely.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

To get a 'jag sound' with a strat...
I 'd play the neck pickup with a big amount of mid range on the amp and with lots of imagination —

www.LosVenturas.be

One of the biggest differences in a Strat and Jag pickup is the metal claw on the Jag pickup.
While Leo devised this to try to help with noise, interference, hum, it changes the inductance of what is otherwise a Strat pickup in windings and geometry.
This is what accounts for the difference in sound between the two pickups.
You could get closer to the Jag sound, pickup wise, by adding baseplates to your Strat pickups.
This would help to approximate the Jag sound, scale length aside.

https://www.fralinpickups.com/product/prepped-baseplate/

http://www.facebook.com/CrazyAcesMusic
http://www.youtube.com/user/crazyacesrock
http://www.reverbnation.com/crazyacesmusic

The jazzmaster pickup is very different with a wide flat winding

the difference between strat and Jaguar pickups are more minor. The jag pickup is taller and therefore has more windings generally. The claw supposedly focuses/narrows the pickup’s field though I’m not so sure that’s reality.

Strat pickups and Jaguar pickups could sound very similar. I built a strat with Jaguar pickups years ago and it basically just sounded like a strat. I think most of the difference in tone comes from the difference in bridges, wiring, and scale length.

-Eric

New music!
https://thedesolatecoast.bandcamp.com/releases
Spotify

Also:
https://theverb.bandcamp.com/
https://www.facebook.com/theverbseattle/

CrazyAces wrote:

One of the biggest differences in a Strat and Jag pickup is the metal claw on the Jag pickup.
While Leo devised this to try to help with noise, interference, hum, it changes the inductance of what is otherwise a Strat pickup in windings and geometry.
This is what accounts for the difference in sound between the two pickups.
You could get closer to the Jag sound, pickup wise, by adding baseplates to your Strat pickups.
This would help to approximate the Jag sound, scale length aside.

https://www.fralinpickups.com/product/prepped-baseplate/

That makes a lot of sense. The “claw” undoubtedly has an effect, increasing the inductive reactance of the pickup. In the Gretsch world, there are Filtertrons with screws for pole-pieces and Supertrons, which are identical, except for the fact that there is a pair of solid bars, which add some inductive reactance and make the pickup sound a bit stronger.

I don’t currently have a Strat, but I have been thinking in terms of adding another guitar to the collection. A Strat with a bit more authority might do the trick and make the acquisition that much easier. I know that there are Strat models that have a way to use the neck and bridge pickups simultaneously, without the middle pickup being on, via the S1 switch.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

cirecc wrote:

The jazzmaster pickup is very different with a wide flat winding

the difference between strat and Jaguar pickups are more minor. The jag pickup is taller and therefore has more windings generally. The claw supposedly focuses/narrows the pickup’s field though I’m not so sure that’s reality.

Strat pickups and Jaguar pickups could sound very similar. I built a strat with Jaguar pickups years ago and it basically just sounded like a strat. I think most of the difference in tone comes from the difference in bridges, wiring, and scale length.

Likewise, some good points. The Strat bridge is bound to have an effect, because the mass of the body and the strings are only tied together via the pivot points of the floating bridge.

I would opine that the claw probably has an effect. Pickups are about magnetic lines of force, so it would make sense that the claw has at least some effect, although that Is not to suggest that the claw is the whole of the story.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

synchro wrote:

Likewise, some good points. The Strat bridge is bound to have an effect, because the mass of the body and the strings are only tied together via the pivot points of the floating bridge.

I would opine that the claw probably has an effect. Pickups are about magnetic lines of force, so it would make sense that the claw has at least some effect, although that Is not to suggest that the claw is the whole of the story.

Yes, if you start factoring in all the physical differences in the two guitars, not just pickups, many other factors come into play.
The vibrato systems on both guitars contribute/diminish to the "tone" greatly. The steel block, string through on the Strat, the top mount, lowers string angle, longer string length behind the bridge on a Jag....
Having mixed and matched a lot of these details on builds I can easily say it all matters, affects sound/tone.
There are many easy ways to get the neck and bridge pickup combination on a Strat, from mix knobs, toggles, S1 switch......
All geometry on a pickup matters. Width of the coil, height of the coil, polepiece type, baseplate or none, material of the baseplate..... and on and on.

http://www.facebook.com/CrazyAcesMusic
http://www.youtube.com/user/crazyacesrock
http://www.reverbnation.com/crazyacesmusic

An easy way I’ve found very jag-like sound from a strat is to mod it so you can have only neck + bridge. Not as honky but plenty chimey. I got a tech to install a push pull pot, where pulled out the bridge is always on. Then I just move the selector switch to neck.

I know practically nothing about it, but the jazzmaster magnets are shorter than Strat and jaguar magnets. Maybe 1/4” compared to 1/2” or 3/8” or something.

Daniel Deathtide

CrazyAces wrote:

synchro wrote:

Likewise, some good points. The Strat bridge is bound to have an effect, because the mass of the body and the strings are only tied together via the pivot points of the floating bridge.

I would opine that the claw probably has an effect. Pickups are about magnetic lines of force, so it would make sense that the claw has at least some effect, although that Is not to suggest that the claw is the whole of the story.

Yes, if you start factoring in all the physical differences in the two guitars, not just pickups, many other factors come into play.
The vibrato systems on both guitars contribute/diminish to the "tone" greatly. The steel block, string through on the Strat, the top mount, lowers string angle, longer string length behind the bridge on a Jag....
Having mixed and matched a lot of these details on builds I can easily say it all matters, affects sound/tone.
There are many easy ways to get the neck and bridge pickup combination on a Strat, from mix knobs, toggles, S1 switch......
All geometry on a pickup matters. Width of the coil, height of the coil, polepiece type, baseplate or none, material of the baseplate..... and on and on.

Everything contributes, including the short scale. I'm not in love with the Jaguar/Jazzmaster bridge and tailpiece. I had one let me down at a gig once. I like the idea of a solid mounted tune-o-matic on an offset.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

DeathTide wrote:

An easy way I’ve found very jag-like sound from a strat is to mod it so you can have only neck + bridge. Not as honky but plenty chimey. I got a tech to install a push pull pot, where pulled out the bridge is always on. Then I just move the selector switch to neck.

I know practically nothing about it, but the jazzmaster magnets are shorter than Strat and jaguar magnets. Maybe 1/4” compared to 1/2” or 3/8” or something.

Makes sense.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

The length of the strings behind the bridge of the Jaguar (and Jazzmaster) do make a noticeable contribution to the overall sound. The ghost tones created as those bits resonate create somewhat discordant sounds and maybe some harmonics that feed into the pickups, especially the bridge. That cannot be replicated in a guitar with a stratocaster tremolo, so Jag pickups in a strat are not going to be the same, and a hardtail Jag will also not sound the same.

And I suspect with a Jag where the trem is moved closer to the bridge, you would be changing those tones as well - hard to say how much, though.

edwardsand wrote:

The length of the strings behind the bridge of the Jaguar (and Jazzmaster) do make a noticeable contribution to the overall sound. The ghost tones created as those bits resonate create somewhat discordant sounds and maybe some harmonics that feed into the pickups, especially the bridge. That cannot be replicated in a guitar with a stratocaster tremolo, so Jag pickups in a strat are not going to be the same, and a hardtail Jag will also not sound the same.

And I suspect with a Jag where the trem is moved closer to the bridge, you would be changing those tones as well - hard to say how much, though.

Good point. Ultimately, I guess it comes done to making our choices and living with the results. Maybe I should just suck it up and get another Jaguar. Who needs two kidneys? Smile

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

edwardsand wrote:

And I suspect with a Jag where the trem is moved closer to the bridge, you would be changing those tones as well - hard to say how much, though.

I forgot to address this in my initial reply. The Offsets sort of fizzled out in the ‘70s, and I think that a lot of this was related to the reputation of Offset bridges, whether deserved or not. I’ve seen, and played the Player’s Edition MIM Jag’ with the sharper break angle over the bridge, and a tune-o-matic bridge. It seemed competent enough, but I didn’t spend enough time with it to form an opinion regarding the effect of their design change in the sound.

That’s sort of the enigma of the Jaguar. They were all but forgotten in the market and the Alternative and Grunge guys bought them for a steal. But they weren’t really made for chunking out power chords, so many of these guitars were modified into something hybrid, neither fish nor fowl.

When I first learned to play, the Jaguar was a holy grail instrument, being the top of Fender’s line. Heck, I couldn’t even afford a Fender Mustang, at the time, but a sunburst Jag seemed like a dream. (I really wanted a Country Gentleman, but that was not going to happen while my parents were paying the bills.) Now I have the Country Gent, but I still can’t get the Jaguar off my mind. Smile

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

image
image
image
image

That’s quite interesting. I know from experience that the CIJ Jaguar pickups can be quite shrill. I replaced them with Seymour Duncan pickups on my ‘66 RI and with Fender US RIs on my Bass VI.

The artist formerly known as: Synchro

When Surf Guitar is outlawed only outlaws will play Surf Guitar.

synchro wrote:

That’s sort of the enigma of the Jaguar. They were all but forgotten in the market and the Alternative and Grunge guys bought them for a steal. But they weren’t really made for chunking out power chords, so many of these guitars were modified into something hybrid, neither fish nor fowl.

I guess I count as one of those Alternative guys - I got my sunburst '67 for $300 in 1985, and it's been my favorite guitar ever since. One thing is that I've played short-scale guitars from the beginning - my first 6 string was a cheap Japanese Mustang-like guitar (as seen in my pic), so the 24 inch scale seems natural to me. I'm fine with other scales as well.

Those magnetic field pictures are pretty cool. You can definitely see the effect the a has on it. I’d be curious to see how that cij pickup compares to other jag pickups. I have a feeling visually it’ll be the same.

-Eric

New music!
https://thedesolatecoast.bandcamp.com/releases
Spotify

Also:
https://theverb.bandcamp.com/
https://www.facebook.com/theverbseattle/

Goto Page: 1 2 Next
Top